As fecal transplant, fecal infusion, fecal implant, or FMT (all different names for the same thing) grow in acceptability, and can often deliver miraculous results, more people with IBD or intestinal infection (like C. difficile) are giving this therapy a try.
If you haven’t heard of it, it’s basically taking poop from a healthy donor and inserting it into the colon of the afflicted person. The rationale is that a healthy human microbiota contains hundreds of species of beneficial organisms, so just taking a probiotic supplement isn’t going to be enough for people in extreme stages of gut disease.
However, what are the possible issues with fecal transplant?
The first thing I have to say, is the same thing I say in my books… people have got to stop looking for the magic pill. For the one solution, the one cure, the one remedy. If your gut imbalance has progressed to a serious or chronic condition, there is just not going to be one drug/herb/procedure/therapy that will heal all the layers of your dis-ease.
The gut biofilm is a component that’s often misunderstood (the same way most people don’t understand the difference between microbiota and microbiome) so here’s a great description from Dr. Chris Kresser (I recommend you read his entire article):
“While planktonic bacteria can become antibiotic resistant through gene mutations, a biofilm is often antibiotic resistant for many reasons—physical, chemical, and genetic. Treating illnesses associated with biofilms using antibiotics is an uphill battle. For example, in patients suffering from IBD, antibiotics appear initially to work, only to be followed by a “rebound,” where the symptoms again flare up, presumably due to bacteria evading the antibiotic within a biofilm.”
*Note that in Kresser’s article, he lists oregano oil as one of the solutions to the biofilm issue.
The big piece I see missing with fecal transplant is the same piece I see missing from the SC Diet (another program that is very good at putting people into remission). Both protocols focus on eradicating pathogens from the gut – one starves them out, the other uses drugs+healthy feces to kill them. But neither advocates for rebuilding the gut flora – in the degree or frequency that is needed to successfully create and maintain a strong, robust microbiota.
Yes, fecal implant relies on the healthy poop to repopulate the colon with good bacteria. But what about the stomach, small intestine, and esophagus? And more importantly, what happens after the fecal implant(s) stop?
One of my readers (who has since passed away) used my protocols to heal his daughter’s ulcerative colitis. Then, as he is an MD, he set up a clinic dedicated entirely to fecal implant. In one of our conversations, he told me he discovered that fecal transplant must be done ongoing, to keep the client from relapsing.
So yes, fecal transplant can be very effective or helpful as part of the wholistic healing process necessary for Inflammatory Bowel Disease – especially if done correctly, with the appropriate safety measures. But I would use it in conjunction with addressing/healing all the factors that lead to IBD or IBS.
My holistic 8 key steps to healing inflammatory bowel disease (described in detail in Listen To Your Gut) are:
- Providing bowel rest using a special elemental (pre-digested) liquid diet or easily tolerated liquified foods
- Killing off the bad bacteria and fungus in the gut (using Jini’s Wild Oregano Oil Protocol)
- Re-populating the gastrointestinal tract with good bacteria (therapeutic-grade probiotic)
- Healing intestinal inflammation and ulceration
- Resolving nutritional deficiencies
- Detoxing your living environment
- Healing the contributing emotional factors (this is HUGE – don’t skip this step!)
- Balancing your hormones
Each one of these steps is crucial and ideally, all need to be done simultaneously. That’s why people need to be ready to commit to holistic healing. It’s not an easy pathway. There is no one solution and it’s an up-and-down, or ascending spiral type of pathway – not a straight line from A-Z.
But is it worth it?? As someone with over 2 decades clear of all drugs or surgery, 3 healthy pregnancies (none of my children have any gut disorder), and the ability to travel and eat all over the world (including third world countries) – as my daughter would say, “Heck yeah!”
p.s. And YES I take my Natren probiotics with me when I travel – packed on ice 🙂
Well this is a mouthful of information. I have been dealing with chronic IBS, which has caused SIBO for the past 7 years. I’ve tried your protocol of Oil of Oregano and have done several elemental diets. I’ve used FM practitioners referred by Chris Kresser’s office, three of them, all knowledgable and with slightly varied supplements and plans and none of those worked. To say that I am frustrated is an understatement. I will say that I do believe that until you deal with the underlying emotional causes that either caused the original dis-ease and/or prevent healing, then all the supplements in the world will not help. I am in the midst of being treated by a hypnotherapist which is helping quite a bit with restoring normal bowel movements. I hope once that is stable I can then address the SIBO. I also am doing affirmations, (both subliminal and not), as much as possible, and by that I mean every free moment or even while I’m doing other things. It’s essential to change the mindset about one’s current state of health. I find that I have to act as if I am already healed and not to think of myself as a chronically sick person. I’ve suffered from years of stress and I basically wiped out my bodies defenses. The mental work is helping with this. But I am still so confused as to what supplements to take since I have stopped taking any as I was not having any success with any of them. I also believe that probiotics is a very difficult subject to make gross recommendations as some brands and strains will work for some people and not others. So when I hear health professionals, such as yourself, recommending certain brands, I am very skeptical. I’ve tried Natren, as you recommend, for months without any positive gains. It is very frustrating trying to figure out which might work and still I might not know if it’s the probiotics, prebiotics, or
other bacterial killing herbs that are not working well. Still, because of the mental/emotional work that I am doing I am very hopeful. I just wish I could feel positive about the physical treatment part.
Jesse it sounds to me like your body is guiding you to exactly what it needs. And you’re getting good results! So why not just press on with that?
Perhaps you can trust that when the time comes for a physical supplement, your body will let you know. And then you will also be able to choose which products, and dosage, according to your unique body’s wisdom.
If I were you, I would incorporate that goal into your emotional/psychological/spiritual development and healing plan – to get your own intuition strong enough that you can hear and dialogue with your body.
Months is not long enough to re-balance a gut flora – yes you should see some positive shift (or a whole lot of die-off) but to change your microbiota in today’s environment probably takes a good 2 years.
I still take Natren every day, but I don’t take the same species/amount every day. I let my body choose what/when/how much it wants. And if I go a week or two without probiotics I’m still fine. But my body asks for them and needs them to maintain VIBRANT health. I don’t consume yoghurt or a significant amount of any other cultured food on a daily basis, so the probiotics are missing from my diet, unless I supplement.
I actually love your story, and thank you so much for taking the time to share it with us. I keep talking about the importance of WHOLE healing but it’s very hard for people to understand and believe that it is as CRUCIAL as anything we do physically – sometimes (often?) moreso. Thank you Jesse!
A word of caution to anyone taking/thinking of taking Natren products.
I received my package of probiotics that were meant to be kept in ice. (That’s what they were using at the time).
Their web site states that they must be kept cold at ALL times.
I opened the box.
The ice blocks had melted, the contents were warm.
I called the company.
They said they would be fine!!
I was at a loss.
Either they need to be kept cold at all times or they don’t.
I believe I paid for and spent months ingesting useless dust.
No effect whatsoever.
I e-mailed the company.
Nothing.
Be aware. They aren’t cheap.
By the way.
I bought them as I was following Jini’s protocol after purchasing her books.
This stopped me in my tracks.
I was very disappointed.
Nice one Jini.
Some great advice here and throughout your web site but when it comes to affecting your profits, re my warning regarding Natren charging a fortune for dead dust, that advice is withheld.
Hope your conscience is clear!!
Sorry Lewie – just found all 3 of your comments in the “possible spam” folder – no idea why!
Now, to address your first comment – which company did you order from? From Natren.com?
And where do you live that the contents were warm in January? Or did someone bring your box inside after delivery? Just trying to get a clearer picture of what happened…